But above all things, my brethren, swear not, neither by heaven, neither by the earth, neither by any other oath: but let your yea be yea; and your nay, nay; lest ye fall into condemnation. James 5:12
On August 9, 2015, I wrote a post called Doug Hagmann:A Man In Deep Trouble in response to an insight which Doug Hagmann had provided into his own soul as he wrote about Planned Parenthood. I commented, But what is most interesting about Hagmann’s article is the darkness of his own philosophy. This he discloses in his opening sentences, saying, “As an investigator and in particular, when I was working as an operational asset for the FBI in the 1990’s, I was particularly good at securing covert video like that captured by the Center for Medical Progress of Planned Parenthood. In fact, I was used because I could convincingly present myself to the subjects of investigation as someone I was not, and secure the needed evidence that served as the basis for immediate raids, arrests and sometimes later, as courtroom exhibits for a jury to see”.
On April 5, 2016 many were discussing news reports of the California Department of Justice raid on the Orange County home of David Daleiden, the anti-abortionist activist. That same evening, after reviewing these events on The Hagmann Report, at the 56:37 minute mark, Doug Hagmann remarked, “…and the Center for Medical Progress being sued by Planned Parenthood – that’s just a nuisance lawsuit to bankrupt these people and I’m no stranger to those – by idiots – like that. Planned Parenthood, deep pockets – we’re going to take Center for Medical Progress and, and sue them, that’s eh, there’s no basis for that suit – in my view – knowing what I know just about the evidence. But see in today’s world you can sue anyone for anything just about and, and the way to do it is just to run up the legal bills, run up the legal expenses because you gotta fight back. Never settle with these idiots – NEVER!”
So who is this David Daleiden who is finding himself at the receiving end of civil lawsuits and criminal investigations, and why is Doug Hagmann personally relating to this man’s woes? If you are unfamiliar with the background of this story, a quick introduction to David Daleiden, is found on Wikipedia. In this post, I link to several articles on the web which provide interesting facts on this story. However, because the abortion issue is highly charged, the reader should be aware that most articles do not reflect impartial journalism and reveal a bias in their analysis.
In an article entitled, Who is the 26-Year-Old Man Behind the Planned Parenthood ‘Sting’ Videos?, Jenifer Gerson Uffalussy on July 21, 2015 wrote, “David went through CMC (Claremont McKenna College) in three years, says Ralph A. Rossum, who taught Daleiden in the classroom and later served as his senior thesis advisor. Rossum serves as Salvatori professor of American constitutionalism in the Department of Government at Claremont McKenna and is an expert on constitutional law and interpretation and has authored books on both Clarence Thomas and Antonin Scalia, two of the current Supreme Court’s most conservative members.”
She adds, “Rossum told Yahoo Health that he was immediately impressed with the young man he describes as a “bright and able kid”. Daleiden took one of Rossum’s courses in the fall of 2009; Rossum describes him as “a basically quiet student. There was no pontificating there on his part whatsoever.” The topic of Daleiden’s senior thesis, which Rossum described as a “tour de force, a great piece of work.” was personhood in American abortion law and jurisprudence…”.
Further insight into Daleiden is found in Meet the millennial who infiltrated the guarded world of abortion providers, an article written October 14, 2015 by Sandhya Somasshekhar for the Washington Post. In referring to David Daleiden’s plan to infiltrate Planned Parenthood at the senior levels, the author quotes Troy Newman’s personal response to Daleiden as, “We will have to deeply embed ourselves — and by we, I mean you, ”. The author then relates, “Daleiden then went to Dallas to meet with Crutcher, who gave him the same advice. Daleiden recalled: “He said, ‘You can’t just put on a lab coat and walk in the front door.’ So Daleiden developed an elaborate ruse. He posed as Robert Daoud Sarkis, an employee of Biomax Procurement Services LLC, a fake company he concocted to serve as a front for the operation. He registered the company with the California secretary of state, set up a mock Web site and even created Facebook pages for his fake employees.”
On May 7, 2013 the Internal Revenue Service granted a charitable tax exemption to The Center For Medical Progress located then at 5325 Elkhorn Blvd, 305, Sacramento, CA 95843 and assigned an EID # 46-2252984. This information can be located on CMP’s Donate page as well as a copy of form 1023 showing that for the years 2013, 2014, and 2015, revenues were $120,000, $80,000 and $80,000 respectively, totaling $280,000.
The Chief Executive Officer, David Daleiden received a $30,000 per year salary for each of these three years; whereas the Chief Financial Officer, Albin Rhomberg and the Secretary, Troy Newman were paid $-0- . The total for Expenses for 2013, 2014, and 2015 under the professional fees category were respectively listed as $50,000 and $10,000 and $10,000. For each of the three years $40,000 was identified as expenses not categorized. Thus apart from the salary paid over 3 years totaling $90,000 to the CEO, we are not provided with the details as to how the remaining funds totaling $190,000 were spent.
Troy Newman’s bio can be found at Wikipedia, stating that he was born in 1966, and is President of Operation Rescue. Newman was raised Roman Catholic, but later joined the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA). He attended Whitefield Theological Seminary, graduating from Maranatha Baptist University, and apparently worked for a time as an electronic engineer in the aerospace industry.
On October 11, 2013 a company called BIOMAX PROCUREMENT SERVICES LLC registered with the California Secretary of State under filing #201328910257 and is still active. On 4/9/2016 when I looked up this company, the CA SOS noted that the Registered Agent had resigned as of July 7, 2015. The website, biomaxps.com presently is invisible to the public and requires a password to login. Biomax’s IP address of 188.8.131.52 also hosts another company’s webpage, that of cmp.org or The Center For Medical Progress which shows a creation date of 4/23/1998. I am not sure what the explanation is for a creation date of almost 18 years ago.
One of the more interesting reads on Biomax Procurement Services, LLC can be found at Rewire News in a July 28, 2015 article written by Sharona Coultts and Sofia Resnick headlined Exclusive: The Faces and Fake Names of People Behind Planned Parenthood Attack Videos. The subtitle of this article says, “Rewire has identified at least three names that appear to have been used as pseudonymns by Center For Medical Progress operatives. One of these names appears to belong to a childhood acquaintance of the group’s apparent ringleader, David Daleiden.” The reader should take a good look at the fake business cards and the photo of fake Biomax employees.
We find for example, that in the prior Rewire News article, a copy of the business card which had been used by David Daleiden as he posed undercover as Robert Daoud Sarkis, Procurement Manager/VP Operations for Biomax. This alias follows him into the world of the courtroom as the National Abortion Federation (NAF) as Plaintiff on July 31, 2015 had filed a court document asking for a temporary restraining order against defendants The Center For Medical Progress; Biomax Procurement Services LLC; David Daleiden (aka “Robert Sarkis”), and Troy Newman.
David Daleiden says he was raised as a cultural Roman Catholic, and in high school became interested in abortion issues. Later he became involved in running his college campus’s chapter of Live Action, which conducts undercover activities at various abortion facilities. This group was founded by Lila Rose who later converted to Catholicism from evangelical Protestantism. With regard to these anti-abortion activists, People For The American Way, in their Right Wing Watch column, has an interesting article called The Activists and Their Ideology Behind The Latest Attacks on Planned Parenthood. The connection between David Daleiden and Lila Rose and Troy Newman is detailed in this article.
What is interesting when reading various articles about these undercover activities is that several players were recruited as teenagers. While these individuals are bright and full of zeal, one has to wonder if any of their mentors impressed upon them the spiritual and legal implications of becoming undercover operatives. When one crosses the line from being honest before all men, to becoming a deceiver and liar, it is at a great spiritual cost to the soul, as well as to the reputation of Christianity. When the line is crossed from volunteerism to a paid vocation, often the heart motivations also change from “freely ye have received, freely give” (Mt. 10:18b) to “having men’s persons in admiration because of advantage” (Jude 1:16b) Are professional liars really heroes? Another interesting article which again mentions Lila Rose is called Meet the checkered activists behind that ‘shocking’ Planned Parenthood video published by dailydot.com on July 16, 2015 by Dell Cameron.
What we see when focusing in on David Daleiden are several questionable practices. The first is the setting up of a tax exempt charity with Troy Newman as Secretary. Since Newman is almost twice the age of Daleiden, we would hope to see wisdom displayed in his role as mentor. But an organization which Newman had been involved in at one point had lost its tax exempt status. And here we see a newly created tax exempt charity created and a young man of about age 24, David Daleiden is made Chief Executive Officer. Center For Medical Progress pays this young man an annual salary, while on paper Troy Newman receives nothing. We are not told who those professional fees were paid to.
And then tied to this we find a fake company, BioMax Procurement Services, LLC registered with the state of California. We have no idea if any money was funneled through this company, but we do know that persons posed as employees of this company, with fake business cards and fake California driver licenses. There are first hand witness reports as well as video which indicate that David Daleiden AKA Robert Sarkis, encouraged and apparently provided alcohol to the persons which they covertly videotaped. The Digital Media Law Project has written an article on the potential legal liabilities of secretly recording audio and videos of persons where consent has not been obtained. The Inquisitr in their April 7, 2016 article Planned Parenthood: Police Raided Anti-Abortion Activist David Daleiden’s Home Seized “Very Damning” Evidence in fact noted that California law “bans the recording of conversations unless both parties consent or the camera or recorder is in plain sight”.
Then there is the problem that the videos made by the Center For Medical Progress and Biomax Procurement Services, LLC reveal severe editing problems which disallow them as credible evidence in a court setting, as reported in this August 27, 2015 dailykos.com article by Joan McCarter entitled Expert Analysis finds Planned Parenthood videos and transcripts doctored by anti-choice group.
While the evidence of the activities of David Daleiden are being entered into court records in lawsuits involving the National Abortion Federation and Planned Parenthood, legitimate investigative journalists are asking a few questions of their own, as can be seen in this February 2016 slate.com article tagged David Daleiden claimed to be an undercover journalist when he investigated. Written by Dahlia Lithwick, she asks in her headline, Is An Anti-abortionist Activist With A Camera A Journalist? And what would that mean for journalism? The author of this article makes an interesting observation: “It’s hard to locate CMP in the tradition of that kind of noble investigative journalism when, as the New York Times noted in July, they only recently revised the organization’s mission on its website to include it: “Originally it was a nonprofit ‘dedicated to informing and educating both the lay public and the scientific community about the latest advances in regenerative medicine, cell-based therapies, and related disciplines.’ Recently it became ‘a group of citizen journalists dedicated to monitoring and reporting on medical ethics and advances.”
In a naavi.org editorial dated June 28, 2005 in reference to an unrelated event, the concept of journalistic sting operations was addressed.The editorialist for the naavi.org website whose motto encourages, Let’s build a responsible cyber society, states, “According to an article in hvk.org, even the FBI’s sting operations, follow strict ground rules laid down over the years by departmental instructions and rulings of the judiciary. Four such major rules are:
- Sting operations are to be mounted only on persons against whom some evidence of criminality exists and a sting operation is considered necessary for getting conclusive evidence.
- Permission for sting operations must be obtained from appropriate courts or the attorney general. This safeguard has been laid down since those who mount a sting operation themselves commit the offence of impersonation, criminal trespass and making a person commit an offence.
- Where there is evidence of editing of tapes and films, there is an automatic presumption that the recording is probably not authentic.
- There must be a concurrent record in writing of the various stages of the sting operation.”